Far be it from me –

Drug treatment in medicine and psychiatry – papering over important differences

Joanna Moncrieff

Summary: The treatment of mental disorders with drugs is not the same sort of activity as the use of drugs in medicine. Psychiatric drugs do not target underlying disease or symptom-producing mechanisms; they create an altered state of mental functioning that is superimposed on underlying feelings and behaviours. The ethical implications of the two situations are different.

I am grateful to the editor of Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences, Corrado Barbui, for publishing my article about the drug-centred model of understanding drug action in psychiatry back in the autumn of last year, and to Carmine Pariante and Catherine Harmer and Phil Cowen who provide commentaries on the article (1-3). Responding to the commentaries, and engaging in a live debate with Professor Pariante has been helpful in sharpening my ideas, and I am also indebted to some persistent questioners at recent talks I have given!

 Pariante, Harmer and Cowen have…

View original post 2,362 more words

Leave a comment »

The shock of the fall

(2018). The shock of the fall. Psychosis. Ahead of Print.

Source: The shock of the fall

Leave a comment »

The Life of Ryan"

Welcome to The Life of Ryan

The Isle Of Thanet News

News for Ramsgate, Margate, Broadstairs and villages. Winner of KPBA Kent news website 2018, highly commended 2020. Winner commitment to the community 2020

Dave's Deliberations

David Matthew chews over some [mostly Christian] issues

Alternative Psychiatric Narratives

16-17 May 2014, Birkbeck, University of London

Through my Eyes

What's it all about!

Black Isle Media

We Provide The Facts, You Make The Decisions

Policy Press Blog

Publishing with a purpose

Alan's Blog

For what it's worth.....

Dr Goat's Blog

Putting hoof to keyboard to bring you views from the farmyard on public health, public mental health and related issues. And goats. These views are my own, and do not represent those of any organisations or endorse any political perspective - but whatever I'm eating may have been stolen.

Social Anxiety Revealed

the blog of the book

the free psychotherapy network

free psychotherapy for people on low incomes and benefits

Miriam Drori, Author

writer, editor, public speaker


The yearly literary festival in the heart of Buckinghamshire


Campaigning to protect the 2004 Hunting Act

more follows

Because politics isn't just something that happens in the Palace of Westminster

%d bloggers like this: