Far be it from me –

NEW STUDY ON ATTITUDES TOWARDS “SCHIZOPHRENIA” a post from Professor John Read

on June 19, 2015

NEW STUDY ON ATTITUDES TOWARDS ‘SCHIZOPHRENIA’

Study published this week, with Lorenza Magliano’s great research team in Naples………

Confirms all the previous studies showing that bio-genetic causal beliefs and diagnostic labelling, are associated with negative attitudes.

These findings are important because they show, yet again, that the ‘mental illness is an illness like any other’ approach, adopted by many ‘destigmatisation’ programmes (especially those funded by drug companies), actually makes attitudes WORSE.

A new finding, rather depressing but perhaps unsurprising, is that PSYCHOLOGY students (at least in Italy) become MORE biologically oriented in the course of their training.

All the more reason for psychology lecturers to throw away those old style American textbooks that turgidly and uncritically reify diagnostic categories as chapter headings and then tell us that everything is largely genetically determined.

I strongly recommend, instead, the BPS award winning textbook by John Cromby, Dave Harper and Paula Harvey:
PSYCHOLOGY, MENTAL HEALTH AND DISTRESS
(Yes I am biased, because I co-authoured the ‘Madness’ chapter)

I will be using this textbook for my third year undergraduate paper at Swinburne Uni in Melbourne next semester. Australian mental health services certainly need an injection of social context and critical thinking in the next generation of practitioners. The simplistic, pessimistic medical model is so dominant here, even within non-medical disciplines ! – that it feels like a cross between the UK thirty years ago and the USA today. ECT is on the increase here ! and anti-depressant prescribing is among the very highest in the world.

As always, though, there are heaps of great people pushing for change here.

Community Mental Health Journal
DOI 10.1007/s10597-015-9901-5

THE INFLUENCE OF CAUSAL EXPLANATIONS AND DIAGNOSTIC LABELING ON PSYCHOLOGY STUDENTS’ BELIEFS ABOUT TREATMENTS, PROGNOSIS,
DANGEROUSNESS AND UNPREDICTABILITY IN SCHIZOPHRENIA

Lorenza Magliano
John Read
Angela Rinaldi
Regina Costanzo
Renata De Leo
Giustina Schioppa
Miriam Petrillo

ABSTRACT
This study explored views of 566 Italian psychology students about schizophrenia. The most frequently cited causes were psychological traumas (68%) and heredity (54%).
Thirty-three percent of students firmly believed that people with the condition could recover.

Reporting heredity among the causes, and identifying schizophrenia were both associated with prognostic pessimism, greater confidence in pharmacological treatments and lower confidence in psychological treatments.
Schizophrenia labeling was also associated with higher perception of unpredictability and dangerousness.

Compared to first year students, fourth/fifth year students more frequently reportedheredity among the causes, and were more pessimistic about schizophrenia recovery.

Stigma topics should be included in future psychologists’ education.

Advertisements

2 responses to “NEW STUDY ON ATTITUDES TOWARDS “SCHIZOPHRENIA” a post from Professor John Read

  1. capriofwa says:

    I am sure that R D Laing has said a lot in relation to these sorts of issues particularly in relation to the label “schizophrenia” in the chapter headed “The Schizophrenic Experience” in the book “Politics of Experience”. “The Divided Self” was for me very illuminating as well. Having been through the process so well described by him in that chapter, I can reiterate what he said when he said that what some might describe as a breakdown may well be a breakthrough. The discovery of our true Self sometimes requires destruction of a false personality/ego, terrifying though this might be. I’m currently reading “Going Crazy” edited by Dr. Hendrik M. Ruitenbeek, interesting stuff.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Policy Press Blog

Publishing with a purpose

Women Writers, Women's Books

Interweaving the Conversation, Deepening the Connection

Alan's Blog

Get what you need here.

Dr Goat's Blog

Putting hoof to keyboard to bring you views from the farmyard on public health, public mental health and related issues. And goats. These views are my own, and do not represent those of any organisations or endorse any political perspective - but whatever I'm eating may have been stolen.

Social Anxiety Revealed

the blog of the book

the free psychotherapy network

free psychotherapy for people on low incomes and benefits

An' de walls came tumblin' down

about writing and social anxiety

BeaconLit

The yearly literary festival in the heart of Buckinghamshire

Keeptheban- news

Campaigning to protect the 2004 Hunting Act

more follows

Because politics isn't just something that happens in the Palace of Westminster

the main offender

Tales of living with borderline personality disorder, working in mental health and all the bits in between.

sdbast

Just another WordPress.com site

sunnyclaribel

4 out of 5 dentists recommend this WordPress.com site

victimfocus

Exploring best practice and research in sexual violence. A loud voice in the fight against victim blaming. Written and Managed by Jessica Eaton, Doctoral Researcher in Forensic Psychology

ALT-POLITICS

Politics For The People

Cortical Chauvinism

A site discussing autism related issues

Not quite curvy; definitely real

Tales of a mental mental health campaigner...

%d bloggers like this: